InsightsHigh Value CropsAgrivoltaic Potential on Grape Farms Generates 15x Annual Revenues

Agrivoltaic Potential on Grape Farms Generates 15x Annual Revenues

Agrivoltaic Potential on Grape Farms Generates 15x Annual Revenues

Image: Antoine BOLCATO (RPC) and PV Magazine.


Abstract

The burgeoning expansion of land-focused solar photovoltaic (PV) farms may lead to contention over land use with traditional agriculture. However, this challenge can be mitigated through the implementation of agrivoltaics, a strategy that combines solar PV and farming within the same land parcel. This research examines the feasibility of employing agrivoltaic systems on existing grape farms in India, with a focus on maintaining agricultural productivity. Taking into account the shade tolerance characteristics of grapevines, a thorough techno-economic analysis is conducted to explore PV installation options between the rows of trellises on a grape farm. By evaluating the potential energy generation per unit area and the corresponding economic advantages for farmers across different design possibilities, the study reveals that the integration of agrivoltaic systems can increase the financial worth of grape farms by over 15 times compared to traditional agricultural methods, without negatively impacting grape yields. If this dual-purpose land utilization were to be adopted across the country, it could generate more than 16,000 GWh of electricity, fulfilling the energy needs of over 15 million individuals. Moreover, the implementation of grape-based agrivoltaics in rural regions holds promise for promoting village electrification.

Department of Electrical & Computer Engineering, Michigan Technological University, MI

Department of Materials Science & Engineering, Michigan Technological University, MI

Corresponding author: Michigan Technological University, 601 M&M Building, 1400 Townsend Drive, Houghton, MI 49931-1295 (pearce@mtu.edu) Ph.: 906-487-1466

Keywords: Agrivoltaic; agrisolar; agriculture; photovoltaic; land use; food-energy-water nexus; solar farm

1. Introduction

Fossil fuel combustion for human energy use and concomitant carbon emissions [1] is disturbing the global ecosystem balance [2,3], which threatens future generations [4] the global economy [5]. Fossil fuels are being depleted [6], yet simultaneously there is an increasing negative environmental impact from their continued use [7]. This demands a greater use of renewable energy [8,9] to enable to internalize current externalities [10] and de-carbonize the energy supply [11]. In the past few decades, the continuous technical improvements [12,13] in solar photovoltaic (PV) technology have enabled methods to provide clean and sustainable solar energy [14] while driving down economic costs [15]. The International Energy Agency (IEA) has predicted that 16% of world’s energy demand, which would be approximately 6,000 TWh, would be generated using solar PV by 2050 [16]. Because of the rise in capacity for solar power generation studies have focused on aggressive use of new designs [17] building integrated PV (BIPV) [18,19] and more conventional rooftop PV retrofits estimated over regional [20], city [21,22], municipal district [23], or multiple buildings [24,25]. However, rooftop systems cannot provide all the energy necessary for some regions with high population densities and thus land- based solar PV farms have also been investigated in depth on technical [26] and economic [27,28] and future economic [29]grounds. The aggressive growth of land-based PV farms [30] creates a conflict in t he use of land [31] for generating energy using solar PV or meeting increasing food production demands of the world population [32]. With the world population increasing at the rate of 1.15% per year [33], and the continued failure to adequately nourish the entire world population [34], this problem is becoming more important. Solar module requires a relatively large amount of open space [35]. Prior efforts to convert crop lands to energy generation (e.g. the production of ethanol) have driven up the cost of food [36], primarily impacted the poor [36] and aggravated world hunger [37]. Fortunately, this major disputation of land use can be resolved using the concept of agrivoltaics (i.e. co-developing the same area of land for both solar PV and agriculture) [38].The agrivoltaic concept has proven successful in several systems [38] including solar PV and aloe vera in dry, semi-arid regions [39], lettuce [40], and cherry tomatoes [41]. Most agrivoltaic studies, however, have focused on shade tolerant crops. This study will focus on a the potential of a relativly shade intolerant crop (grapes) in a promising region for agrivoltaic production (India).

India is a particularly promising region for agrivoltaic production because it has an economy that is made up of many agriculture producers [42], and is rapidly expanding electrical services to the 21.3% of India’s population without access to any form of electricity [43]. In addition, India has significant support from the government for PV production and has achieved increasing solar capacities [44]. Finally, India receives a relatively high solar flux. Indian states like Maharashtra, Gujarat, Haryana, Punjab, Rajasthan, Andhra Pradesh, Orrisa, Madhya Pradesh, Bihar, and West Bengal, which form the major part of India, receive 4-7 kWh of solar radiation per square meter per day, which is equivalent to 2,300-3,200 hours of sunshine every year [45].

To investigate and quantify some of this agrivoltaic generation potential, without harming the Indian agriculture output even for shade-intolerant crops, for the first time this study explores the viability of agrivoltaic farms deployment on existing grape farms in India. Considering the weak shade tolerance of grapes, an analysis is run for the installation of PV systems in the area available between the trellises on a grape farm without compromising grape production, which represents a novel approach to agrivoltaics in the use of the necessary harvesting space of shade intolerant crops. Then the electrical energy generation potential is determined per unit area and economic benefits for the grape cultivators is quantified. A sensitivity analysis is run on geographical location, selection of module and inverter, row spacing, selection of axis and azimuth angle. The results are discussed and conclusions are drawn to provide best practices.

2. Background

Grape farms offer considerable promise for agrivoltaic farms. First, grape farms are generally located in areas having a 15-40°C temperature range over a reasonable duration of sunlight hours [46, 47]. Grapes are grown on trellises and the layout of grape farms is such that there is an underutilized gap of about 1.5m to 2.5m between the trellises. Although grapes are normally considered a full sun plant, even in the absence of full sunlight all day long (e.g. even 7-8 hours), it is still possible to grow grapes in mostly shade with some preparation and forethought to maximize yield [48].

One of the method is to more fully utilize the sunlight incident on a standard grape farm is to mount and install solar PV modules in the unused space between trellises. This agrivoltaic geometry for grape farms is schematically represented in Figure 1, where X is the horizontal distance between the solar PV rows towards the south direction, Z is the horizontal distance between the trellis and the solar module, W is the height of trellis and T is the distance from the ground to the bottom of the PV array, and Y is the length (vertical height) of the solar module. It should be noted that for grape farms with small inter-trellis spacing (X-2Z)/2 the standard modules will need to be mounted in landscape format so that Y is what is normally referred to as the width of the module. Finally, as can be seen in Figure 1, the angle, θ, is define as the tilt angle of the solar module with respect to a plane parallel to the ground.

Figure 1. Side view schematic arrangement of solar modules between grape trellises. Note that the middle of the PV module is positioned at approximately the top of the grape crop.

Grape farms in India are predominantly located in the Northwestern part of the State of Maharashtra (known as the “the grape capital of India”), particularly in Nashik [49]. Surrounding industries can be supplied with the electricity from these farms during peak load demands, helping to increase grid reliability [39], while decreasing greenhouse gas emissions from conventional power plants that use fossil-fuel combustion. In this way, the sale of PV electricity can operate as a second source of income for farmers from their existing grape fields. In addition, the irrigation cost of grape farms is a substantial fraction of the farm input costs [64] and there is a considerable evidence that farmers can benefit from using the electricity generated from the solar PV for water pumping for their own needs directly [51-55].

Using the geometry shown in Figure 1, Figure 2a is generated to show the top view arrangement of the solar PV systems in a complete grape-based agrivoltaic system. The PV modules are mounted in series between the trellises in an alternate manner to allow grape farmers access to every plant for pruning, harvesting and other agriculture related tasks. At the same time this allows restricted access to the PV modules for any maintenance related tasks (e.g. periodic cleaning). The variable A describes the width of the farm (east west direction) and the B explains the depth of the farm made up of a multiple of X spacing between rows of modules. The C describes the horizontal width of the PV module projected on the ground, which is Ycos(θ)

and D is the inter-trellis spacing (X-2Z)/2. A scaled-down detail section (9.0m X 9.78m) of an agrivoltaic PV acre array used in the simulations is shown in Figure 2b.

Figure 2a. Top view schematic arrangement of a grape-based agrivoltaic system. Please note that the grape grape trellises are exaggerated to be seen in the top view. They are conventional trellises and would not need to be modified for agrivoltaic production.